Seeing Yourself as a Smoker Again Predicted Later Relapse
Evidence review & editorial synthesis
Quitting smoking changes behavior immediately. Identity can take much longer.
A person may stop buying cigarettes, survive withdrawal and remain abstinent for months or years while some part of them still thinks: I am a smoker who is not smoking right now.
New longitudinal research suggests that distinction may matter. Former smokers whose smoker identity became stronger over time were more likely to relapse later. The finding adds to a growing body of research suggesting that smoking cessation is not only about nicotine, cravings and willpower. It can also involve a change in self-concept.
You can stop smoking before you stop being a smoker
The new study followed former smokers who had quit within the previous five years across four measurement waves over one year.
Researchers repeatedly measured smoker identity, ex-smoker identity, smoking relapse and something called smoking-related self-discontinuity. That last term describes the feeling that quitting has disrupted who you are, as though the person after smoking is disconnected from the person you used to be.
Within individuals, periods of stronger self-discontinuity were associated with stronger smoker identity, and that combination was indirectly associated with greater likelihood of relapse at the following wave.
But the causal story was not as simple as the researchers originally expected. When they imposed a stricter prospective sequence, self-discontinuity did not reliably produce later changes in smoker or ex-smoker identity. Instead, fluctuations in smoking identities sometimes came first and predicted later feelings of self-discontinuity.
The more robust message is therefore not that identity disruption causes relapse in one simple chain. It is that smoker identity itself appears to fluctuate over time and those fluctuations are meaningfully tied to future smoking behavior.
Earlier studies found the same warning signal
This is not the first time that a lingering smoker identity has predicted relapse.
A prospective study of 544 former smokers from Australia and the UK classified people according to how they described themselves after quitting. Those who still thought of themselves as smokers trying to quit were much more likely to relapse over the following year than people who identified as ex-smokers, non-smokers or smokers who had made a firm decision that they no longer smoked.
The distinction is psychologically subtle but important.
There is a difference between saying, 'I am trying not to smoke' and 'I do not smoke.' The first keeps smoking inside the current identity and frames abstinence as an ongoing struggle. The second treats smoking as behavior belonging to a previous version of the self.
Other research shows how slowly that transition can happen. Among former smokers who had been abstinent for at least two years, 37.4% still reported some attraction to cigarettes and 16.3% still retained a smoker identity.
So physical abstinence can persist long before the old identity completely disappears.
Why identity could affect relapse
Smoking is unusually well suited to becoming part of identity because it is repeated thousands of times and woven into routines, emotions and social situations.
A cigarette can become part of drinking coffee, taking work breaks, dealing with stress, socializing, driving or ending a meal. Over years, smoking stops being merely something a person does and can become something that feels characteristic of the person.
When that behavior disappears, the loss can therefore extend beyond nicotine. Familiar rituals vanish. Social relationships may change. Situations previously structured around cigarettes suddenly feel different.
If someone continues to categorize themselves as a smoker, a lapse may also feel more compatible with who they are. One cigarette becomes less of a violation of identity and more of a return to it.
By contrast, a stable non-smoking identity can potentially reverse the psychological equation. Smoking then becomes the behavior that conflicts with the person's current self-concept.
That idea does not make nicotine dependence irrelevant. Cravings, withdrawal, stress, alcohol use and environmental cues remain major relapse factors. Identity may operate alongside them rather than replacing them.
Could quitting treatment deliberately change identity?
This is where the research becomes practically interesting.
Experimental work has tested whether smoking cessation can be framed as a continuation of the person's existing self rather than a loss of it. When participants were encouraged to see quitting as compatible with who they fundamentally were, they developed a stronger ex-smoker identity relative to smoker identity and subsequently engaged more with cessation behaviors.
The direct intervention effect was not large enough to establish identity work as a stand-alone treatment. But it suggests a different therapeutic target.
Instead of asking only, 'How do we stop this person from wanting a cigarette?' cessation programs could also ask, 'How do we help this person reach the point where smoking no longer feels like something they do?'
For a former smoker, that transition may sound almost trivial. The longitudinal evidence suggests it may not be.
The difficult part of quitting may sometimes continue after the last cigarette, until the person no longer experiences abstinence as resisting an old identity and starts experiencing not smoking as simply being themselves.
Scientific References & Further Reading
- Anchor Study: “Self-discontinuity, smoker and ex-smoker identity, and smoking relapse: A multilevel longitudinal study.” (Blondé J, Falomir-Pichastor JM. Self-discontinuity, smoker and ex-smoker identity, and smoking relapse: A multilevel longitudinal study. Applied Psychology: Health and Well-Being. 2026;18(5):e70231. doi:10.1111/aphw.70231.)
- Prospective Relapse Study: “What kind of smoking identity following quitting would elevate smokers relapse risk?.” (Callaghan L, Yong HH, Borland R, et al. What kind of smoking identity following quitting would elevate smokers relapse risk? Addictive Behaviors. 2021;112:106654. doi:10.1016/j.addbeh.2020.106654.)
- Identity Intervention Research: “Self-Discontinuity as a Barrier to Identity and Behaviour Change: Evidence From Smoking Cessation.” (Blondé J, Falomir-Pichastor JM. Self-Discontinuity as a Barrier to Identity and Behaviour Change: Evidence From Smoking Cessation. European Journal of Social Psychology. 2026;56(2):316-330. doi:10.1002/ejsp.70044.)
- Long-Term Former Smoker Study: “Residual attraction to smoking and smoker identity following smoking cessation.” (Vangeli E, Stapleton J, West R. Residual attraction to smoking and smoker identity following smoking cessation. Nicotine & Tobacco Research. 2010;12(8):865-869. doi:10.1093/ntr/ntq104.)
- Dependence and Self-Concept Study: “Tobacco dependence and smoking cessation: The mediating role of smoker and ex-smoker self-concepts.” (Falomir-Pichastor JM, Blondé J, Desrichard O, et al. Tobacco dependence and smoking cessation: The mediating role of smoker and ex-smoker self-concepts. Addictive Behaviors. 2020;102:106200.)
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. It is not a substitute for diagnosis, treatment, or individualized medical care.

